Return of the Obra Dinn character guide: progressive hints and fate entries

Check evidence separately from fate entries by manifest number. Every character answer starts closed, so you can read only the evidence you need.

Edition: PC Steam full game (AppID 653530), primarily Japanese display with PC keyboard/mouse controls. Console buttons and development demos are excluded.

Verification scope: References the official history's default version 1.2.122, history updated September 20, 2022. The distributed build and Japanese in-game inputs on October 4, 2026 were not verified.

Sources checked: 2026-10-04

487 / 487 rows

Searching does not open answer tables. Choose the answer you want to reveal.

Open only the manifest number you need

Numbers match the in-game manifest. “Records to revisit” gives evidence locations and reasoning; “Fate entry” contains identity, role, and example inputs. Evidence can name other people or scenes, so both remain closed.

  1. Choose the manifest number you want to investigate.
  2. To keep deducing, open only Records to revisit.
  3. If you cannot enter the scene, check its corpse entrance in the exploration article.
  4. For the answer, open Fate entry under the same number.

All 60 people are covered, but not every accepted alternative input is listed. Every Japanese input has not been retested in-game on the current PC build. Source-supported primary entries, alternatives, and withheld points are distinguished.

Anonymous-number index

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Anonymous-number index: 60 entries
Manifest numberOpen firstOpen if needed
01Person 01: records to revisitPerson 01: fate entry
02Person 02: records to revisitPerson 02: fate entry
03Person 03: records to revisitPerson 03: fate entry
04Person 04: records to revisitPerson 04: fate entry
05Person 05: records to revisitPerson 05: fate entry
06Person 06: records to revisitPerson 06: fate entry
07Person 07: records to revisitPerson 07: fate entry
08Person 08: records to revisitPerson 08: fate entry
09Person 09: records to revisitPerson 09: fate entry
10Person 10: records to revisitPerson 10: fate entry
11Person 11: records to revisitPerson 11: fate entry
12Person 12: records to revisitPerson 12: fate entry
13Person 13: records to revisitPerson 13: fate entry
14Person 14: records to revisitPerson 14: fate entry
15Person 15: records to revisitPerson 15: fate entry
16Person 16: records to revisitPerson 16: fate entry
17Person 17: records to revisitPerson 17: fate entry
18Person 18: records to revisitPerson 18: fate entry
19Person 19: records to revisitPerson 19: fate entry
20Person 20: records to revisitPerson 20: fate entry
21Person 21: records to revisitPerson 21: fate entry
22Person 22: records to revisitPerson 22: fate entry
23Person 23: records to revisitPerson 23: fate entry
24Person 24: records to revisitPerson 24: fate entry
25Person 25: records to revisitPerson 25: fate entry
26Person 26: records to revisitPerson 26: fate entry
27Person 27: records to revisitPerson 27: fate entry
28Person 28: records to revisitPerson 28: fate entry
29Person 29: records to revisitPerson 29: fate entry
30Person 30: records to revisitPerson 30: fate entry
31Person 31: records to revisitPerson 31: fate entry
32Person 32: records to revisitPerson 32: fate entry
33Person 33: records to revisitPerson 33: fate entry
34Person 34: records to revisitPerson 34: fate entry
35Person 35: records to revisitPerson 35: fate entry
36Person 36: records to revisitPerson 36: fate entry
37Person 37: records to revisitPerson 37: fate entry
38Person 38: records to revisitPerson 38: fate entry
39Person 39: records to revisitPerson 39: fate entry
40Person 40: records to revisitPerson 40: fate entry
41Person 41: records to revisitPerson 41: fate entry
42Person 42: records to revisitPerson 42: fate entry
43Person 43: records to revisitPerson 43: fate entry
44Person 44: records to revisitPerson 44: fate entry
45Person 45: records to revisitPerson 45: fate entry
46Person 46: records to revisitPerson 46: fate entry
47Person 47: records to revisitPerson 47: fate entry
48Person 48: records to revisitPerson 48: fate entry
49Person 49: records to revisitPerson 49: fate entry
50Person 50: records to revisitPerson 50: fate entry
51Person 51: records to revisitPerson 51: fate entry
52Person 52: records to revisitPerson 52: fate entry
53Person 53: records to revisitPerson 53: fate entry
54Person 54: records to revisitPerson 54: fate entry
55Person 55: records to revisitPerson 55: fate entry
56Person 56: records to revisitPerson 56: fate entry
57Person 57: records to revisitPerson 57: fate entry
58Person 58: records to revisitPerson 58: fate entry
59Person 59: records to revisitPerson 59: fate entry
60Person 60: records to revisitPerson 60: fate entry

Names are not listed in search results or headings before opening. Text filtering must not automatically open closed answers.

Example inputs and accepted alternatives

The source's Japanese fields align meanings across references rather than claiming every option's wording and hierarchy was tested. English equivalents identify those meanings here; current on-screen options still take precedence.

  1. Select the person in the name field.
  2. Choose the fate category, then weapon or cause where required.
  3. Fill a killer or destination only if that field appears.
  4. If you later correct a killer's name, also check victim entries using that name.

Additional fields depend on the selected fate. Do not search for fields that are not displayed. Even where alternatives are documented, check names and required fields rather than attributing every rejection to an alternative input.

Person 01: open evidence

Person 01: open evidenceClose

Person 01: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 01: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceX-1Connect calls to the captain with his response from the captain's quarters
Fate correspondenceX-4In X-4 he points a gun at himself

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 01: open fate entry

Person 01: open fate entryClose

Person 01: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 01: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameRobert Witterel
RoleCaptain
Primary example inputSuicide → Gun
Where the fate is recordedChapter 10, The End, Part 4
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 02: open evidence

Person 02: open evidenceClose

Person 02: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 02: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceX-4 + manifest 19Compare the captain's reference to his wife's brother with Abigail's maiden name, Hoscut
Fate correspondenceX-1Shot by the captain in the doorway in X-1

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 02: open fate entry

Person 02: open fate entryClose

Person 02: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 02: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameWilliam Hoscut
RoleFirst Mate
Primary example inputShot → Gun / Robert Witterel
Where the fate is recordedChapter 10, The End, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 03: open evidence

Person 03: open evidenceClose

Person 03: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 03: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIII-1Remember the attacker's face where the victim calls him Nichols
Fate correspondenceIV-6Trace the shot fired from aboard into the boat just before its return

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 03: open fate entry

Person 03: open fate entryClose

Person 03: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 03: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameEdward Nichols
RoleSecond Mate
Primary example inputShot → Gun / Chioh Tan
Where the fate is recordedChapter 4, The Calling, Part 6
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 04: open evidence

Person 04: open evidenceClose

Person 04: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 04: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVII-8Match Abigail calling Martin with the nearby man urging evacuation
Fate correspondenceVIII-4Spiked by the mermaid he tries to release in the stern storeroom

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 04: open fate entry

Person 04: open fate entryClose

Person 04: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 04: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameMartin Perrott
RoleThird Mate
Primary example inputSpiked / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 8, Bargain, Part 4
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpeared / a beast

Alternatives are source-reported accepted examples, not a guarantee of current-PC testing. Match meanings to the displayed fields. This fate cannot yet be confirmed through ordinary ship exploration; see the closed final exploration section for requirements and entrance.

Person 05: open evidence

Person 05: open evidenceClose

Person 05: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 05: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIV-6 + ship planMatch the man looking from the fourth mate's cabin window with the room label
Fate correspondenceIX-5After shooting Wiater, he is struck by Brennan rushing toward him

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 05: open fate entry

Person 05: open fate entryClose

Person 05: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 05: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameJohn Davies
RoleFourth Mate
Primary example inputClubbed / Henry Brennan
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape, Part 5
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 06: open evidence

Person 06: open evidenceClose

Person 06: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 06: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIX-1 + manifest 7The statement that his assistant is French identifies him as bosun's mate Miner's superior
Fate correspondenceIX-1The left-arm tentacle injury in VII-8 connects with the missing arm in IX-1

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 06: open fate entry

Person 06: open fate entryClose

Person 06: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 06: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameAlfred Klestil
RoleBosun
Primary example inputTorn apart / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 07: open evidence

Person 07: open evidenceClose

Person 07: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 07: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIX-1+VII-8Match the French assistant sought by the bosun with the man last helping him
Fate correspondenceVII-8+IX-1The IX-1 testimony about the assistant explains the disappearance after VII-8

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 07: open fate entry

Person 07: open fate entryClose

Person 07: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 07: fate entry: 6 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameCharles Miner
RoleBosun's Mate
Primary example inputTorn apart / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesDrowned / a beast
Unverified candidate not recommended hereEaten / a beast: listed by BHodges080 (2019/Switch) and others. Prefer Torn apart or Drowned; withhold this as an additional current-PC alternative

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 08: open evidence

Person 08: open evidenceClose

Person 08: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 08: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-2 and II-3 + prefaceIdentify the person directing treatment as surgeon; use the preface signature and survival information to distinguish his mate
Fate correspondenceIX-2 and IX-3 + prefaceCompare the escape boat in IX-2/IX-3 with Morocco, the preface's return address

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. Consult exploration for entrances. He is alive at the fate-entry reference time; do not enter the epilogue's later death from illness here

Person 08: open fate entry

Person 08: open fate entryClose

Person 08: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 08: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameHenry Evans
RoleSurgeon
Primary example inputAlive → Africa
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. This entry records where he escaped alive after the voyage, not the epilogue's later events.

Person 09: open evidence

Person 09: open evidenceClose

Person 09: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 09: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-2 and II-3 + prefaceThe other medical worker assists the surgeon. Since the preface establishes Evans survived, the dead medical worker is his mate
Fate correspondenceVI-4His neck is caught in a crab's claw in that scene

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 09: open fate entry

Person 09: open fate entryClose

Person 09: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 09: fate entry: 6 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameJames Wallace
RoleSurgeon's Mate
Primary example inputClawed / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 6, Soldiers of the Sea, Part 4
Alternative wording accepted by referencesDecapitated / a beast
Unverified candidate not recommended hereStrangled / a beast: official 1.1.110 adds strangling for two unnamed people. Wallace's character wiki lists it but Zhang's does not, so neither receives this recommended input here

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 10: open evidence

Person 10: open evidenceClose

Person 10: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 10: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceV-3+VI-3Narrow to the two men in the carpenter's workshop; choose the one addressed as the master in VI-3
Fate correspondenceVI-8Check his wound from the beast's weapon and their mutual defeat on the cargo deck

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 10: open fate entry

Person 10: open fate entryClose

Person 10: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 10: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameWinston Smith
RoleCarpenter
Primary example inputSpeared / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 6, Soldiers of the Sea, Part 8
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpiked / a beast; Clawed / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 11: open evidence

Person 11: open evidenceClose

Person 11: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 11: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceV-3+VI-3Of the two workshop men, the one addressing the other as master is the mate
Fate correspondenceVI-3A creature's projectile pierces him just after he throws an axe

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 11: open fate entry

Person 11: open fate entryClose

Person 11: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 11: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameMarcus Gibbs
RoleCarpenter's Mate
Primary example inputSpiked / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 6, Soldiers of the Sea, Part 3
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpeared / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 12: open evidence

Person 12: open evidenceClose

Person 12: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 12: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceV-2Match the cooking fork and talk of cooking the creature with the manifest's cook
Fate correspondenceV-2The mermaid's tail strikes him directly; distinguish it from nearby spikes

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 12: open fate entry

Person 12: open fate entryClose

Person 12: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 12: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameThomas Sefton
RoleCook
Primary example inputStruck → Tail
Where the fate is recordedChapter 5, Unholy Captives, Part 2
Alternative wording accepted by referencesCrushed / a beast; Clubbed / a beast

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and displayed fields. Japanese references vary on impact-category wording; use the tail as the cause.

Person 13: open evidence

Person 13: open evidenceClose

Person 13: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 13: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-3He directs the cow's butchery. Dialogue and tools distinguish him from the cook
Fate correspondenceVI-6The creature's spikes pin his body near the wall

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 13: open fate entry

Person 13: open fate entryClose

Person 13: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 13: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameEmil O'Farrell
RoleButcher
Primary example inputSpiked / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 6, Soldiers of the Sea, Part 6
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpeared / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 14: open evidence

Person 14: open evidenceClose

Person 14: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 14: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIII-2The captain addresses him by surname; he directs the firing squad
Fate correspondenceVII-4The creature moves the lit cannon in VII-3; it fires at close range in VII-4

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 14: open fate entry

Person 14: open fate entryClose

Person 14: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 14: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameChristian Wolff
RoleGunner
Primary example inputShot → Cannon / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom, Part 4
Alternative wording accepted by referencesShot → Cannon / Abraham Akbar; Exploded

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 15: open evidence

Person 15: open evidenceClose

Person 15: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 15: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVI-7Through the window, he handles weapons with the identified gunner in the armory
Fate correspondenceIX-4The gun fires in Davies's hands as they struggle over it

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 15: open fate entry

Person 15: open fate entryClose

Person 15: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 15: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameOlus Wiater
RoleGunner's Mate
Primary example inputShot → Gun / John Davies
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape, Part 4
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 16: open evidence

Person 16: open evidenceClose

Person 16: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 16: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVI-7 + ship planThrough the port-passage window, locate the person hiding in the purser's office
Fate correspondenceVII-1+VII-7Connect the ledger-carrying escapee in VII-1 with the boat overturned in VII-7

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 16: open fate entry

Person 16: open fate entryClose

Person 16: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 16: fate entry: 6 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameDuncan McKay
RolePurser
Primary example inputDrowned / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesFell → Overboard
Unverified candidate not recommended hereEaten / a beast: listed by BHodges080 (2019/Switch) and others. Prefer Torn apart or Drowned; withhold this as an additional current-PC alternative

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 17: open evidence

Person 17: open evidenceClose

Person 17: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 17: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceJustice at Sea sketchMatch the person at the wheel with the manifest's only helmsman
Fate correspondenceVII-8In VII-8 the creature seizes him near the wheel

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 17: open fate entry

Person 17: open fate entryClose

Person 17: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 17: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameFinley Dalton
RoleHelmsman
Primary example inputDrowned / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesEaten / a beast; Crushed / a beast; Torn apart / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 18: open evidence

Person 18: open evidenceClose

Person 18: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 18: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceSketch signature + III-2Match E.S. on the sketch with the manifest; also observe him drawing in III-2
Fate correspondenceVII-2A tentacle crushes him at the bow's toilet area

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 18: open fate entry

Person 18: open fate entryClose

Person 18: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 18: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameEdward Spratt
RoleArtist
Primary example inputCrushed / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom, Part 2
Alternative wording accepted by referencesStrangled / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 19: open evidence

Person 19: open evidenceClose

Person 19: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 19: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceX-4+VII-8Combine the captain's address, talk of his wife, and the compound surname
Fate correspondenceVII-8A broken yard falls onto her

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 19: open fate entry

Person 19: open fate entryClose

Person 19: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 19: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameAbigail Hoscut Witterel
RolePassenger
Primary example inputCrushed → Rigging
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom, Part 8
Alternative wording accepted by referencesCrushed / a beast; Clubbed / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 20: open evidence

Person 20: open evidenceClose

Person 20: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 20: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIII-2Connect the victim named before the execution with the preceding murder scene
Fate correspondenceIII-1Inspect Nichols's hands and the contact point in III-1

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 20: open fate entry

Person 20: open fate entryClose

Person 20: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 20: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameNunzio Pasqua
RolePassenger
Primary example inputKnifed / Edward Nichols
Where the fate is recordedChapter 3, Murder, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 21: open evidence

Person 21: open evidenceClose

Person 21: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 21: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVII-8 and IX-2 + manifest 22Distinguish the two female passengers other than Abigail using the ring and the manifest's Miss honorific
Fate correspondenceIX-2 and IX-3 + prefaceLeaves in Evans's boat in IX-3; the preface identifies Morocco as the destination

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 21: open fate entry

Person 21: open fate entryClose

Person 21: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 21: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameEmily Jackson
RolePassenger
Primary example inputAlive → Africa
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. This entry records where he escaped alive after the voyage, not the epilogue's later events.

Person 22: open evidence

Person 22: open evidenceClose

Person 22: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 22: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVII-8 and IX-2 + manifest 21Identify Jackson by the ring first, then assign the remaining woman to the Miss entry
Fate correspondenceIX-2 and IX-3 + prefaceEscapes in the same boat as Evans, Jackson, and James

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 22: open fate entry

Person 22: open fate entryClose

Person 22: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 22: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameMiss Jane Bird
RolePassenger
Primary example inputAlive → Africa
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. This entry records where he escaped alive after the voyage, not the epilogue's later events.

Person 23: open evidence

Person 23: open evidenceClose

Person 23: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 23: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIII-2 + Formosan Royalty sketchMatch the address to Lim with the corresponding person in the royal sketch
Fate correspondenceIV-4The beast's claw attacks her neck from IV-3; she dies in IV-4

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 23: open fate entry

Person 23: open fate entryClose

Person 23: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 23: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameBun-Lan Lim
RolePassenger
Primary example inputClawed / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 4, The Calling, Part 4
Alternative wording accepted by referencesStrangled / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 24: open evidence

Person 24: open evidenceClose

Person 24: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 24: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIV-2Match the person Lim calls Beng with It-Beng in the manifest
Fate correspondenceIV-5Puts his hand in the chest in IV-4 and suffers arm damage across the next scene

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 24: open fate entry

Person 24: open fate entryClose

Person 24: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 24: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameIt-Beng Sia
RolePassenger
Primary example inputBurned
Where the fate is recordedChapter 4, The Calling, Part 5
Alternative wording accepted by referencesElectrocuted; Poisoned

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 25: open evidence

Person 25: open evidenceClose

Person 25: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 25: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIII-2 and IV-2 + royal sketchIdentify Lau, Lim, and Sia in the royal sketch first; the remaining person follows
Fate correspondenceV-1A spike passes through him while restrained and through the seaman behind him in V-1

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 25: open fate entry

Person 25: open fate entryClose

Person 25: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 25: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameChioh Tan
RolePassenger
Primary example inputSpiked / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 5, Unholy Captives, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpeared / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 26: open evidence

Person 26: open evidenceClose

Person 26: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 26: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIII-2His name is explicitly given as the person being executed
Fate correspondenceIII-2Trace trajectories from all four guns and select Brennan's bullet that hits

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 26: open fate entry

Person 26: open fate entryClose

Person 26: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 26: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameHok-Seng Lau
RolePassenger
Primary example inputShot → Gun / Henry Brennan
Where the fate is recordedChapter 3, Murder, Part 2
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 27: open evidence

Person 27: open evidenceClose

Person 27: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 27: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondencePresent-day steward's room + other stewardsMatch the uniform with clothes in the steward's room; exclude the four mates' stewards and captain's steward
Fate correspondenceVI-7The back spike is not fatal. Trace VI-7's bullet path, wall hole, and shooter through the window

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 27: open fate entry

Person 27: open fate entryClose

Person 27: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 27: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameZungi Sathi
RoleShip's Steward
Primary example inputShot → Gun / Charles Miner
Where the fate is recordedChapter 6, Soldiers of the Sea, Part 7
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 28: open evidence

Person 28: open evidenceClose

Person 28: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 28: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceV-4Identify the man reprimanded by the captain as his long-serving steward
Fate correspondenceVIII-1He puts an arm into the chest in the stern storeroom and dies after it is damaged

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 28: open fate entry

Person 28: open fate entryClose

Person 28: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 28: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameFillip Dahl
RoleCaptain's Steward
Primary example inputBurned
Where the fate is recordedChapter 8, Bargain, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesElectrocuted; Poisoned

Alternatives are source-reported accepted examples, not a guarantee of current-PC testing. Match meanings to the displayed fields. This fate cannot yet be confirmed through ordinary ship exploration; see the closed final exploration section for requirements and entrance.

Person 29: open evidence

Person 29: open evidenceClose

Person 29: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 29: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIX-2Read the warning that names Paul, also checking the deceased speaker marker
Fate correspondenceIX-2Defending the escape boat, he is stabbed by Volkov's sword

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 29: open fate entry

Person 29: open fate entryClose

Person 29: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 29: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NamePaul Moss
RoleFirst Mate's Steward
Primary example inputKilled (Sword) / Leonid Volkov
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape, Part 2
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 30: open evidence

Person 30: open evidenceClose

Person 30: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 30: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIII-2+IV-3Combine the steward uniform with his whispering to and accompanying Nichols
Fate correspondenceIV-3After freeing himself, Sia knifes his neck

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 30: open fate entry

Person 30: open fate entryClose

Person 30: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 30: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameSamuel Galligan
RoleSecond Mate's Steward
Primary example inputKnifed / It-Beng Sia
Where the fate is recordedChapter 4, The Calling, Part 3
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 31: open evidence

Person 31: open evidenceClose

Person 31: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 31: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVII-2Follow the man carrying dishes to identified Perrott; check the steward uniform
Fate correspondenceVII-5Caught between a sliding cannon and the wall

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 31: open fate entry

Person 31: open fate entryClose

Person 31: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 31: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameRoderick Andersen
RoleThird Mate's Steward
Primary example inputCrushed → Cannon
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom, Part 5
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 32: open evidence

Person 32: open evidenceClose

Person 32: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 32: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIII-2・VI-3・VII-2Combine the steward uniform with his continuing attendance on Davies
Fate correspondenceIX-2 and IX-3 + prefaceAccompanies the surgeon and two women in the IX-2/IX-3 escape boat

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 32: open fate entry

Person 32: open fate entryClose

Person 32: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 32: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameDavey James
RoleFourth Mate's Steward
Primary example inputAlive → Africa
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. This entry records where he escaped alive after the voyage, not the epilogue's later events.

Person 33: open evidence

Person 33: open evidenceClose

Person 33: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 33: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-3+IX-6+VII-6Separate three similarly uniformed midshipmen. Match Peter, whom Lanke tried to save, with the person being rescued in VII-6
Fate correspondenceVII-6The gunpowder he carries explodes when the creature captures him

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 33: open fate entry

Person 33: open fate entryClose

Person 33: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 33: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NamePeter Milroy
RoleMidshipman
Primary example inputExploded
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom, Part 6
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 34: open evidence

Person 34: open evidenceClose

Person 34: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 34: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-3+IX-6Use the uniform to identify a midshipman; exclude Hershtik and Milroy. The person describing Peter's rescue is not Peter
Fate correspondenceIX-6Connect the IX-3 pursuer and the knife in his back in IX-4/IX-5 with the fatal injury

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 34: open fate entry

Person 34: open fate entryClose

Person 34: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 34: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameThomas Lanke
RoleMidshipman
Primary example inputKnifed / Olus Wiater
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape, Part 6
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 35: open evidence

Person 35: open evidenceClose

Person 35: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 35: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-3Read the address to the midshipman vomiting at the butchery. Distinguish him from the same-named bosun's mate by uniform
Fate correspondenceVI-5Grapples with the burning creature and is caught in flames and weapons

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 35: open fate entry

Person 35: open fate entryClose

Person 35: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 35: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameCharles Hershtik
RoleMidshipman
Primary example inputBurned
Where the fate is recordedChapter 6, Soldiers of the Sea, Part 5
Alternative wording accepted by referencesKilled (Sword) / Peter Milroy; Speared / a beast; Spiked / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 36: open evidence

Person 36: open evidenceClose

Person 36: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 36: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVI-4+VII-2Match his curved sword with the same weapon beside hammock 36
Fate correspondenceVII-6Observe him falling seaward from the rigging in the background of VII-6

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 36: open fate entry

Person 36: open fate entryClose

Person 36: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 36: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameOmid Gul
RoleTopman
Primary example inputFell → Overboard
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesDrowned / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 37: open evidence

Person 37: open evidenceClose

Person 37: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 37: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1+III-3Match the design on the arm extending from hammock 37 with his tattoo at death
Fate correspondenceIII-3Shot by Nichols fleeing into the boat

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 37: open fate entry

Person 37: open fate entryClose

Person 37: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 37: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameTimothy Butement
RoleTopman
Primary example inputShot → Gun / Edward Nichols
Where the fate is recordedChapter 3, Murder, Part 3
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 38: open evidence

Person 38: open evidenceClose

Person 38: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 38: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1+III-2・VI-1Match the black shoes with white edging and socks at hammock 38 with the feet on the mast
Fate correspondenceVI-1Lightning passes through him in the rigging

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 38: open fate entry

Person 38: open fate entryClose

Person 38: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 38: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameHuang Li
RoleTopman
Primary example inputElectrocuted
Where the fate is recordedChapter 6, Soldiers of the Sea, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. If footwear differs from an older reference, also use numbers, possessions, and adjacent moments rather than one visual detail.

Person 39: open evidence

Person 39: open evidenceClose

Person 39: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 39: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1+VI-1・VI-4Match number 39's white shoes and striped socks with his feet on the mast or at death
Fate correspondenceVI-4His neck is caught in the same crab claw as Wallace

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 39: open fate entry

Person 39: open fate entryClose

Person 39: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 39: fate entry: 6 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameJie Zhang
RoleTopman
Primary example inputClawed / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 6, Soldiers of the Sea, Part 4
Alternative wording accepted by referencesDecapitated / a beast
Unverified candidate not recommended hereStrangled / a beast: official 1.1.110 adds strangling for two unnamed people. Wallace's character wiki lists it but Zhang's does not, so neither receives this recommended input here

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. If footwear differs from an older reference, also use numbers, possessions, and adjacent moments rather than one visual detail.

Person 40: open evidence

Person 40: open evidenceClose

Person 40: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 40: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1+IV-1+VII-2Match the interpreter with manifest topman candidates. Solve 38/39's footwear first and exclude 41, who remains later
Fate correspondenceIV-1Struck by a mermaid's thrown spear in the first attack

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 40: open fate entry

Person 40: open fate entryClose

Person 40: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 40: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameLi Hong
RoleTopman
Primary example inputSpeared / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 4, The Calling, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpiked / a beast

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. If footwear differs from an older reference, also use numbers, possessions, and adjacent moments rather than one visual detail.

Person 41: open evidence

Person 41: open evidenceClose

Person 41: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 41: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVII-2+II-1Match hammock 41 with his position at the meal; also check when others in the group die
Fate correspondenceVII-8Seized from the rigging in VII-8 and disappears afterward

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 41: open fate entry

Person 41: open fate entryClose

Person 41: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 41: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameWei Lee
RoleTopman
Primary example inputDrowned / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesEaten / a beast; Crushed / a beast; Torn apart / a beast

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. If footwear differs from an older reference, also use numbers, possessions, and adjacent moments rather than one visual detail.

Person 42: open evidence

Person 42: open evidenceClose

Person 42: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 42: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVI-3+VI-2Connect the next scene's report that Nicholas fell with the preceding attack victim
Fate correspondenceVI-2A boarding crab rider's spear pierces his chest

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 42: open fate entry

Person 42: open fate entryClose

Person 42: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 42: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameNicholas Botterill
RoleTopman
Primary example inputSpeared / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 6, Soldiers of the Sea, Part 2
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpiked / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 43: open evidence

Person 43: open evidenceClose

Person 43: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 43: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVI-1 + the other nine topmenConfirm his topman duties on the mast; identify the other nine independently and select the remainder
Fate correspondenceVII-7Two tentacles pull his upper and lower body apart

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 43: open fate entry

Person 43: open fate entryClose

Person 43: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 43: fate entry: 6 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameMaba
RoleTopman
Primary example inputTorn apart / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom, Part 7
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above
Unverified candidate not recommended hereCrushed / a beast: found only in GameLine VII. Torn apart is recommended; current-PC verification of the alternative is withheld

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. If footwear differs from an older reference, also use numbers, possessions, and adjacent moments rather than one visual detail.

Person 44: open evidence

Person 44: open evidenceClose

Person 44: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 44: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondencePresent-day hammock 44 + VI-1 + IX-6The surviving hammock 44 narrows him to late survivors; mast duties and Brennan's address distinguish him
Fate correspondenceX-3The captain strikes his head with a long weapon

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 44: open fate entry

Person 44: open fate entryClose

Person 44: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 44: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameLewis Walker
RoleTopman
Primary example inputClubbed / Robert Witterel
Where the fate is recordedChapter 10, The End, Part 3
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpeared / Robert Witterel

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 45: open evidence

Person 45: open evidenceClose

Person 45: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 45: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1+VI-1Of three men playing cards in Russian, choose the topman climbing the mast in VI-1
Fate correspondenceIX-3Killed by Jackson shooting from the boat

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 45: open fate entry

Person 45: open fate entryClose

Person 45: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 45: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameLeonid Volkov
RoleTopman
Primary example inputShot → Gun / Emily Jackson
Where the fate is recordedChapter 9, Escape, Part 3
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 46: open evidence

Person 46: open evidenceClose

Person 46: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 46: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1+VI-1+IV-1Exclude topman Volkov and pipe-smoking Toporov from the Russian-speaking trio
Fate correspondenceIV-2Pulled into the sea by a mermaid beside IV-2's boat

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 46: open fate entry

Person 46: open fate entryClose

Person 46: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 46: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameAlarcus Nikishin
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputDrowned / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 4, The Calling: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesClawed / a beast; Fell → Overboard

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 47: open evidence

Person 47: open evidenceClose

Person 47: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 47: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1+III-3・IV-1Match the bag and pipe beside 47 with possessions in the boat and the smoker
Fate correspondenceIV-3Dragged from the boat by a mermaid in IV-3

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 47: open fate entry

Person 47: open fate entryClose

Person 47: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 47: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameAleksei Toporov
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputDrowned / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 4, The Calling: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesClawed / a beast; Fell → Overboard

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 48: open evidence

Person 48: open evidenceClose

Person 48: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 48: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVII-1+VII-2His accusation over his brother's death and the remaining hammock 48 identify the surviving Peters
Fate correspondenceVII-1+VII-7The boat he boards in VII-1 is hurled into the sea in VII-7's background

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 48: open fate entry

Person 48: open fate entryClose

Person 48: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 48: fate entry: 6 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameNathan Peters
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputDrowned / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesFell → Overboard
Unverified candidate not recommended hereEaten / a beast: listed by BHodges080 (2019/Switch) and others. Prefer Torn apart or Drowned; withhold this as an additional current-PC alternative

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 49: open evidence

Person 49: open evidenceClose

Person 49: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 49: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVII-1 + manifestMatch the reference to a Dane with the manifest's one matching nationality
Fate correspondenceVII-1Clubbed by Peters in the escape boat

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 49: open fate entry

Person 49: open fate entryClose

Person 49: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 49: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameLars Linde
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputClubbed / Nathan Peters
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 50: open evidence

Person 50: open evidenceClose

Person 50: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 50: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceV-4Combine the address John with a deck worker's clothes to distinguish him from mate Davies
Fate correspondenceV-4Combine the severed leg, nearby sword, and conversation about the detained Dahl

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 50: open fate entry

Person 50: open fate entryClose

Person 50: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 50: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameJohn Naples
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputKilled (Sword) / Fillip Dahl
Where the fate is recordedChapter 5, Unholy Captives, Part 4
Alternative wording accepted by referencesTorn apart / Fillip Dahl

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 51: open evidence

Person 51: open evidenceClose

Person 51: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 51: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1Match the exposed face sleeping in hammock 51 with the manifest
Fate correspondenceII-2Infirmary dialogue and his weakened body establish death from illness

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 51: open fate entry

Person 51: open fate entryClose

Person 51: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 51: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameRenfred Rajub
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputIllness
Where the fate is recordedChapter 2, A Bitter Cold, Part 2
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 52: open evidence

Person 52: open evidenceClose

Person 52: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 52: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1Match four seamen using Hindi dialogue and sleeping places. Exclude 51/53/54 to identify the person using the X-marked hammock
Fate correspondenceVII-3Crushed between a tentacle-moved cannon and the hull

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 52: open fate entry

Person 52: open fate entryClose

Person 52: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 52: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameAbraham Akbar
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputCrushed → Cannon
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom, Part 3
Alternative wording accepted by referencesCrushed / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 53: open evidence

Person 53: open evidenceClose

Person 53: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 53: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1The man standing apart from 51, 54, and the X-hammock user corresponds to the unused 53
Fate correspondenceV-3The creature-carrying group collapses; his neck is injured beneath the stretcher and stairs

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 53: open fate entry

Person 53: open fate entryClose

Person 53: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 53: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameWilliam Wasim
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputCrushed → Cargo
Where the fate is recordedChapter 5, Unholy Captives, Part 3
Alternative wording accepted by referencesCrushed / a beast; Fell → Stairs

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 54: open evidence

Person 54: open evidenceClose

Person 54: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 54: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1Match the spoken surname Syed with berth 54
Fate correspondenceII-1Check his severe coughing and the surgeon's explanation in II-2

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 54: open fate entry

Person 54: open fate entryClose

Person 54: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 54: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameSoloman Syed
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputIllness
Where the fate is recordedChapter 2, A Bitter Cold, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 55: open evidence

Person 55: open evidenceClose

Person 55: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 55: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceI-1+II-1+VII-2Narrow to deck workers. Identify 59 separately; of 55/57, exclude 57 who survives later
Fate correspondenceV-1One spike passes through restrained Tan and him behind

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 55: open fate entry

Person 55: open fate entryClose

Person 55: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 55: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameHamadou Diom
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputSpiked / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 5, Unholy Captives, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpeared / a beast

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. If footwear differs from an older reference, also use numbers, possessions, and adjacent moments rather than one visual detail.

Person 56: open evidence

Person 56: open evidenceClose

Person 56: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 56: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIX-6Follow the man Hoscut addresses by surname to request medical tools; the other nearby man is topman Walker
Fate correspondenceX-2The captain cuts his neck with a knife. Do not confuse a neck wound with decapitation

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 56: open fate entry

Person 56: open fate entryClose

Person 56: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 56: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameHenry Brennan
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputKnifed / Robert Witterel
Where the fate is recordedChapter 10, The End, Part 2
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 57: open evidence

Person 57: open evidenceClose

Person 57: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 57: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVII-1・VII-2+VI-7Exclude Nathan and the purser in the boat; match the remaining seaman with surviving berth 57
Fate correspondenceVII-1+VII-7The beast overturns the escape boat with all three aboard in VII-7

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 57: open fate entry

Person 57: open fate entryClose

Person 57: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 57: fate entry: 6 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameAlexander Booth
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputDrowned / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom: missing people
Alternative wording accepted by referencesFell → Overboard
Unverified candidate not recommended hereEaten / a beast: listed by BHodges080 (2019/Switch) and others. Prefer Torn apart or Drowned; withhold this as an additional current-PC alternative

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. If footwear differs from an older reference, also use numbers, possessions, and adjacent moments rather than one visual detail.

Person 58: open evidence

Person 58: open evidenceClose

Person 58: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 58: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceIV-3+IV-1・IV-2Narrow O'Hagan's address to the person just felled in the boat. Exclude Hong and Toporov using other evidence
Fate correspondenceIV-2A mermaid's thrown spear pierces his neck

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 58: open fate entry

Person 58: open fate entryClose

Person 58: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 58: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NamePatrick O'Hagan
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputSpeared / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 4, The Calling, Part 2
Alternative wording accepted by referencesSpiked / a beast

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Person 59: open evidence

Person 59: open evidenceClose

Person 59: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 59: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceII-1+VII-2Match berth 59's location with the person facing 41 in VII-2
Fate correspondenceVII-4Near the muzzle in VII-3 but gone in VII-4; record him as a victim of that same shot

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 59: open fate entry

Person 59: open fate entryClose

Person 59: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 59: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameGeorge Shirley
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputShot → Cannon / a beast
Where the fate is recordedChapter 7, The Doom, Part 4
Alternative wording accepted by referencesShot → Cannon / Abraham Akbar; Exploded; Fell → Overboard; Drowned / a beast; Eaten / a beast

Alternatives are source-reported examples rather than current-PC tests. Match meanings and actual fields. If footwear differs from an older reference, also use numbers, possessions, and adjacent moments rather than one visual detail.

Person 60: open evidence

Person 60: open evidenceClose

Person 60: records to revisit

Check identity evidence separately from evidence of what happened. A correct name can still have the wrong killer, so avoid treating one observation as proof of both.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 60: records to revisit: 2 entries
Field to investigateScene or record to revisitHow evidence connects
Face-to-manifest correspondenceVII-1・VII-2+I-1Revisit I-1 for the brothers' accident. Since 48 remains later, the deceased brother is 60
Fate correspondenceI-1The hoisting rope breaks and cargo crushes him

Roman numerals identify chapters; the number after the hyphen is the part. If the present-day entrance is unclear, consult the exploration guide.

Person 60: open fate entry

Person 60: open fate entryClose

Person 60: fate entry

This section includes the person's name, role, and an example fate entry.

Wide tables scroll horizontally.

Person 60: fate entry: 5 entries
FieldAnswer or caution
NameSamuel Peters
RoleSeaman
Primary example inputCrushed → Cargo
Where the fate is recordedChapter 1, Loose Cargo, Part 1
Alternative wording accepted by referencesNo additional alternative listed; prioritize the primary input above

Alternatives are accepted examples reported by references, not a guarantee every candidate was tested on current PC. If UI wording differs, match the English meaning and actual displayed fields.

Frequently asked questions

Is a correct name enough?

Also fill the fate, required weapon or subtype, and any killer or destination. Identity and fate evidence may be in different scenes.

Do I need a death scene for everyone in the manifest?

Some people have no recorded moment of death. Closed character evidence also identifies where to compare disappearances and book statements.

Can one person have multiple accepted causes?

Some accept more than one wording. The table separates primary entries from documented alternatives; it is not an exhaustive in-game test table.

I entered an answer, but nothing happened.

The normal system does not confirm each person individually. Check names, causes, and additional fields one entry at a time, and consult the closed final exploration section if near the end.

🔥Popular guides
  1. 1Brotato Character Tier Comparison: First Clear and Danger 5 Picks
  2. 2Dungeon Clawler Builds: 4 Early Choices and 6 Character Builds
  3. 3Brotato Build Guide: Weapons, Upgrades and Pitfalls for 8 Characters
  4. 4Everything is Crab Walkthrough — Early Decisions to Higher Pressure
  5. 5Mouthwashing Walkthrough and Collectibles Guide

Based on site-wide views, captured July 6, 2026 (previous 28 days plus capture day).